Monday, March 10, 2014

Barbie & Body Image

Nickolay Lamm of MyDeals.com
[source]
I read an article this morning about a new "averaged size" doll, meant to provide a healthy alternative to Barbie's unrealistic body proportions.  She's shorter, with a shorter neck and flat feet; and she's obviously not as skinny.  Apparently, that's a better doll for little girls to play with.  It kind of irritated me, although I'm not completely sure why.

Maybe it's because I don't think Barbie is to blame for poor body image.  When I was growing up, the more Barbies I could get my hands on, the better.  I not only wanted Barbie, I wanted her sister, younger brother, boyfriend, house..and don't forget the pink convertible.  Although I can't say for sure [it was a long time ago] it's almost certain that I thought Barbie was beautiful!  Who wouldn't?  She had an endless wardrobe of swimsuits, ballgowns, and high heels.

But I never felt like I had to look like her.  Her arms didn't even bend.  [Until they released Gymnast Barbie, which I bought with my birthday money when I was 7.]  It's fairly obvious she has disproportionate measurements.  Being skinny is only one piece of what makes Barbie unrealistic--she has a long neck, huge eyes, unusually big hair that comes out in chunks if you try to brush it, pointy feet, and is tall enough to be in the NBA.  Do little girls try to copy those traits, too?

Maybe I'm naive, but I feel like kids are fairly innocent. They play 'house' with their Barbies.  Then pretend they're the mother of a chubby doll.  Then all of a sudden, My Little Ponies are flying through the air.  Imaginative stuff.  Make pretend.  Sorry kids, you can't play like that- it's not realistic.  Barbie is too skinny, 5-yr-olds don't have babies and ponies can't fly.  

[source]
I'm much quicker to blame poor body image on real role models.  Mothers.  Sisters.  Neighbors.  Friends.  The people that influence the way we talk, eat, dress, and interact with others.  Watching real people obsess about weight, scales, and calories will teach a girl that she's fat, not a doll.

I think I grew up with a very healthy body image, because no one around me ever talked about weight.  It was a non-issue.  Of course I went through phases of insecurity as I got older, but it was the result of trying to look like the people around me, not like Barbie.  So when I hear people say they don't let their kids play with Barbies I feel like those kids are missing out on a critical piece of childhood.  It's like taking away Disneyland.

I've also been thinking about body image recently because after having a baby, my body obviously didn't look how I wanted it to look.  But I never looked in the mirror and disliked myself.  I just didn't really recognize myself.  I was trying to dress a very different body with the clothes in my closet.  [Like fitting a square peg in a round hole...]  And I wasn't completely content because I knew I wanted to be healthier.

Now that I've made some changes to become healthier (and got some clothes that fit) I actually feel really good about my body!  I'm not where I was before having a baby.  But so what.  I can still be happy with now.

None of this is scholarly.  Just my rambling thoughts.  I'd be curious to know if other people's body images were really influenced by the dolls they played with growing up.  I hope in the future I can maintain a positive outlook and not be drawn to compare myself to others.  Because to the extent that we are dissatisfied with or reflection in the mirror, our kids will also be dissatisfied.  And Barbie isn't to blame.

3 comments:

  1. My experience is similar, except people did talk about weight. And even though all my sisters and I were skinny it has backfired as we have gotten older and our bodies have changed. I don't think Barbie is to blame for poor body image, but I do think she raises an expectation that is exacerbated in the media, magazines, etc. Barbie isn't real, but she is hyper-sexualized and so I don't see the harm in producing a doll that is more realistic. I let my kids play with Barbie (or would if she weren't so expensive!), but I'll be up for buying a more normal-looking doll as well. Ultimately, body image is something they'll be dealing with for a very long time--far longer than they'll be playing with dolls.

    ReplyDelete
  2. If dolls influenced our kids as much as they seem to be saying we should have let our kids play with those Cabbage Patch dolls. Who wants their kids to think they should have double chins and bald heads!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I actually thought about the Cabbage Patch dolls when I read the Barbie article. They're the exact OPPOSITE of barbie. And maybe since we had both it balanced things out?

      Delete